A softly sunlit neutral living room with an ivory sofa, oak coffee table and limestone fireplace beside a window overlooking a late-autumn garden.

How Far Below Asking Mineola Homes Sold This Fall

  • November 19, 2026

In September, a five-bedroom Mineola home on Trotwood Avenue sold for $3,200,000. It has 4,650 square feet, a 19-foot foyer with a floating white oak and glass staircase, and a heated in-ground pool. The list price was $3,598,888, so the buyer paid about $400,000 under asking, according to INsauga's September roundup.

A gap of about 11% between list and sale is wider than Mineola's headline ratios suggest, and the decline in Mineola values is smaller than its headline averages suggest. Both point to the same conclusion. This fall, the common summary figures understate how much negotiating is going on and overstate how far values have fallen. If you are weighing Mineola against Lorne Park or Port Credit, you need both points to read the neighborhood correctly.

The Homes for Sale and the Homes That Sell

As of mid-November 2026, MLS data showed 62 detached homes for sale in Mineola. The median asking price was $2.7M and the median asking price per square foot was $991. The six detached homes that sold in October 2026 had a median sold price of about $1.4M and a median of $725 per square foot.

The median asking price is almost double the median sold price, which means the homes for sale and the homes that sold are different groups. The middle of the current inventory is priced well above where the middle of October's sales closed. Six sales in one month is a small sample, so no single month settles anything. Still, a $1.3M gap between the middle listing and the middle sale is too wide to put down to chance.

The per-square-foot gap is narrower, about 27%, and it is the better guide to how much asking prices are stretched. Comparing price per square foot removes most of the effect of house size, so what is left is closer to a pure pricing gap.

The Average Fell Faster Than Values Did

TRREB's quarterly community report shows 16 detached sales in Mineola in Q3 2026. The average price was $1,552,000 and the median was $1,216,000. In Q3 2025, the same report showed 23 detached sales at an average of $2,177,000 and a median of $1,625,000.

That is roughly a 29% drop in the average and a 25% drop in the median from one third quarter to the next. Over the same stretch, the median sold price per square foot for Mineola detached homes from August to October 2026 was down 16.1% from the same three months a year earlier.

The difference between those figures is mostly about which homes sold. If every home had lost about a sixth of its value but the same kinds of homes had kept selling, the average would have dropped by about a sixth too. It dropped by more than a quarter. That suggests this year's 16 sales leaned toward less expensive homes than last year's 23 did.

For a buyer, a 16% decline in price per square foot is a real change in what a Mineola home costs. The 29% decline in the average is real arithmetic, but it says as much about which listings found buyers as about what any one house is worth.

Where the Discount Hides

The October sale-to-list ratio for Mineola detached homes was 95%. On its own, that suggests buyers are getting about five percent off. A different measure gives a different answer. From August to October 2026, Mineola detached homes sold for a median 91.8% of their first asking price.

The two numbers differ because of relisting. When a seller takes a home off the market and puts it back on at a lower price, MLS treats that as a new listing, and the earlier, higher price drops out of the sale-to-list calculation. From August through October, 18 detached homes sold in Mineola, 28 came back at a lower price, and 25 were withdrawn without being relisted. More homes were relisted lower than sold. That is why the 95% figure looks generous and the 91.8% figure looks closer to how negotiations are actually going.

The top of the market shows the same pattern in named sales. INsauga's monthly lists of the most expensive homes sold in Mississauga reported these Mineola results this year, the March sales and the September sales among them:

Address Sale month List price Sold price Sold vs. list
1617 Trotwood Ave. September 2026 $3,598,888 $3,200,000 about 89%
1271 Mineola Gardens March 2026 $3,350,000 $3,050,000 about 91%
1456 Glenburnie Rd., Mineola West March 2026 $4,350,000 $4,000,000 about 92%

All three of these homes sold for $3 million or more, and each closed between $300,000 and $400,000 under its list price.

How Mineola Compares With Its Neighbors

Mineola is a slower market than Mississauga as a whole, and the gap is larger than the price headlines show. TRREB reported 200 detached sales in Mississauga in October 2026, with 894 active listings, a 97% average sale-to-list ratio and an average of 32 days on market. That works out to about four and a half months of supply at October's pace.

October 2026 snapshot Mineola detached Mississauga detached
Months of inventory 10.3, at the August–October sales pace about 4.5, at the October sales pace
Sale-to-list ratio 95% 97%
Median sold price about $1.4M $1,150,000

At about ten months of supply, a buyer in Mineola can be selective in a way that is harder in the city overall.

Nearby high-end sales closed closer to their final list prices this year. In Lorne Park, 807 Indian Rd., a five-bedroom home renovated in 2025, sold in October for $2,660,000 against a $2,699,850 list price. In August, 821 Parkland Ave. near Rattray Marsh sold for $1,955,000 against $1,995,000. 1004 Caldwell Ave. sold for $1,816,000 against $1,999,999. In Port Credit, 8 Cumberland Dr. sold in September for $2,707,000 against $2,749,000, and 76 Ben Machree Dr. sold in July for $3,125,000 against $3,245,000.

Those comparisons use final list prices, so they share the same blind spot as Mineola's 95%. Even so, most of the Lorne Park and Port Credit results landed within a few percent of list. The Mineola results in the table above landed eight to eleven percent under. Buyers comparing the three neighborhoods this fall have the most room to negotiate in Mineola, especially among homes listed above $3 million.

Pricing a Mineola Home From Sold Data

For a buyer, the most useful number on a Mineola listing is its first asking price, along with whether the home has already been relisted. A home that came back at a lower price has already shown how it stands against the market. A home on its first listing at a price per square foot well above the $725 median for October's sales is likely aiming above where sales have been closing. Our new-build versus character homes guide for Mineola compares the two kinds of homes found on the neighborhood's streets.

For an owner thinking about selling, the same numbers point the other way. Recent sales in the neighborhood are the right comparison, and active listings around the corner are not. With 62 homes for sale and about six detached sales a month over the past three months, a well-presented home priced against what has actually sold stands out more than one priced against its neighbors' listings. Our market report tracks these figures month by month.

Mineola Market FAQ

Have Mineola home values really dropped by almost a third? No. The Q3 detached average fell about 29% from 2025 to 2026, and much of that reflects a change in which homes sold. The median sold price per square foot for August to October 2026 was down 16.1% year over year, which is a closer measure of how much an individual home's value has changed.

Are Mineola homes above $3 million selling at all? Yes. 1617 Trotwood Ave. sold in September 2026 for $3,200,000, and 1456 Glenburnie Rd. sold in March 2026 for $4,000,000. Both closed below their list prices.

Why does the October sale-to-list ratio look stronger than the first-ask figure? Relisted homes start a new MLS listing, so the 95% October ratio compares sold prices with prices that have already been cut. The 91.8% figure for August to October tracks each home back to its first asking price.

If you own a home here and want to know where it falls against those sales, the Larose Team will prepare a valuation built on closed Mineola sales. Request a Free Home Valuation.

Follow Us

Work With Us

Our goal is to make the process as easy as possible for you. Gain access to our extensive network of established and preferred vendors and service providers whom we trust and have built long-lasting relationships with.